Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) Price Target Analysis
Updated Jul 2, 2026
Analyst Rating: Buy
Based on 5 analysts10.0% Below Target
NIC trades 10.0% below Wall Street's consensus target of $182.67.
Current Price$166.12
Average Target$182.67
Target
Current
Low$173.00
Median$185.00
High$190.00
Analyst Target Range
Forward P/E13.9x
(Value)
PEG Ratio1.22
(Fair)
Implied Growth+36.3%
(High Growth)
Analyst Spread9.3%
(High Agreement)
Price Forecast (1 Year)
Last 12 months price action with 12-month analyst target path
Consensus Scenario Assumptions
The base valuation assumes NIC achieves its forward estimates and maintains a stable P/E multiple of 13.9x. This scenario reflects the blended consensus of 5 Wall Street analysts, balancing both positive catalysts and macroeconomic headwinds over the next 12 months.
NIC Price Target Analysis
Updated July 7, 2026As of July 7, 2026, Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) has a Wall Street consensus price target of $182.67, based on estimates from 5 covering analysts. With the stock currently trading at $166.12, this represents a potential upside of +10.0%. The company has a market capitalization of $2.61B.
Analyst price targets range from a low of $173.00 to a high of $190.00, representing a 9% spread in expectations. The median target of $185.00 aligns closely with the consensus average. The tight target dispersion indicates high conviction among analysts.
The current analyst consensus rating is Buy, with 3 analysts rating the stock as a Buy or Strong Buy,2 rating it Hold, and 0 rating it Sell or Strong Sell. The positive sentiment balance indicates moderate optimism about the stock prospects.
From a valuation perspective, NIC trades at a trailing P/E of 17.0x and forward P/E of 13.9x. The forward PEG ratio of 1.22 indicates reasonable valuation for growth. Analysts expect EPS to grow +36.3% over the next year.
Our proprietary valuation model, which blends historical multiples with forward estimates, suggests a base-case price target of $184.63, with bear and bull scenarios of $116.32 and $243.27 respectively. Model confidence stands at 56/100, reflecting moderate uncertainty in projections.
Investment Context: Price targets represent analyst expectations for the next 12 months and should be considered alongside your own research. Targets are based on analysts' assumptions about earnings growth, margins, and market conditions which may change. For sector-specific context, view other Financial Services stocks.
Analyst Sentiment Comparison
Industry Peer AnalysisAvg Peer Upside
+11.8%
Industry Consensus
Avg Forward P/E
11.9x
(Value)
Peers with Coverage
7 / 10
Active Analyst Tracking
| Company | Market Cap | Price | Target | Upside Potential | Rating | Fwd P/E | Analysts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 IBCPIndependent Bank Corporation | $740M | $35.90 | $38.00 | +5.8% | Hold | 10.1x | 7 |
 FFINFirst Financial Bankshares, Inc. | $5.0B | $34.75 | $39.25 | +12.9% | Hold | 17.1x | 15 |
 BANFBancFirst Corporation | $3.8B | $114.30 | $125.00 | +9.4% | Hold | 15.6x | 3 |
 OTTROtter Tail Corporation | $3.8B | $90.49 | $81.00 | -10.5% | Hold | 15.9x | 7 |
 NBTBNBT Bancorp Inc. | $2.6B | $50.16 | $56.00 | +11.6% | Hold | 12.0x | 10 |
 MBWMMercantile Bank Corporation | $1.0B | $57.93 | $58.50 | +1.0% | Buy | 10.6x | 7 |
 CFFIC&F Financial Corporation | $263M | $80.79 | — | — | — | 7.8x | — |
 BWFGBankwell Financial Group, Inc. | $466M | $58.44 | — | — | Buy | 10.8x | 3 |
 CZWICitizens Community Bancorp, Inc. | $223M | $23.10 | — | — | Buy | 12.7x | 2 |
 FISFidelity National Information Services, Inc. | $21.3B | $41.27 | $62.88 | +52.4% | Buy | 6.6x | 37 |
NIC — Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions about buying NIC stock.
What is the NIC stock price target for 2026?
Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) has a consensus 12-month price target of $182.67, implying 10.0% upside from $166.12. The 5 analysts covering NIC see moderate appreciation potential.
Is NIC a buy, sell, or hold?
NIC has a consensus rating of "Buy" based on 5 Wall Street analysts. The rating breakdown is predominantly bullish, with 3 Buy/Strong Buy ratings. The consensus 12-month price target of $182.67 implies 10.0% upside from current levels.
Is NIC stock overvalued or undervalued?
With a forward P/E of 13.9222x, NIC trades at a relatively low valuation. The consensus target of $182.67 implies 10.0% appreciation, suggesting meaningful undervaluation.
How high can NIC stock go?
The most bullish Wall Street analyst has a price target of $190 for NIC, while the most conservative target is $173. The consensus of $182.67 represents the median expectation. Our quantitative valuation model projects a bull case target of $243 based on optimistic growth and margin assumptions. These targets typically reflect 12-month expectations.
How many analysts cover NIC stock?
NIC is moderately covered, with 5 analysts providing price targets and ratings. Of these, 0 have Strong Buy ratings, 3 have Buy ratings, 2 recommend Hold, and 0 have Sell or Strong Sell ratings. Higher analyst coverage generally indicates greater institutional interest and more reliable consensus estimates.
What is the NIC stock forecast?
The 12-month NIC stock forecast based on 5 Wall Street analysts shows a consensus price target of $182.67, with estimates ranging from $173 (bear case) to $190 (bull case). The median consensus rating is "Buy". Our proprietary valuation model produces a base case fair value of $185, with bear/bull scenarios of $116/$243.
What is NIC's fair value based on fundamentals?
Our quantitative valuation model calculates NIC's fair value at $185 (base case), with a bear case of $116 and bull case of $243. The model uses discounted cash flow analysis, historical growth rates, and margin mean-reversion to project FY+2 earnings, then applies an appropriate P/E multiple. The model confidence score is 56/100.
What is NIC's forward P/E ratio?
NIC trades at a forward P/E ratio of 13.9x based on next-twelve-months earnings estimates compared to a trailing P/E of 17.0x. The lower forward P/E indicates analysts expect earnings growth. A forward P/E is useful for comparing valuations when earnings are expected to change significantly.
Should I buy NIC stock?
Wall Street analysts are optimistic on NIC, with a "Buy" consensus rating and $182.67 price target (10.0% upside). 3 of 5 analysts rate it Buy or Strong Buy. This information is for educational purposes only. Always conduct your own research, consider your financial situation, and consult a financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Why do NIC price targets vary so much?
NIC analyst price targets range from $173 to $190, a 9% tight range reflecting strong analyst consensus. Differences stem from varying assumptions about revenue growth, profit margins, competitive dynamics, and valuation multiples. The $182.67 consensus represents the middle ground. Our model's $116-$243 range provides an independent fundamental perspective.
Consensus-Based Analysis Tools
Intrinsic Valuation
DCF models, multiple analysis, and analyst estimates.
Check Valuation
Historical Returns
10-year return with dividends reinvested.
Calculate
DCA Calculator
See how regular investing compounds over time.
Run Numbers
Peer Comparison
Compare growth, multiples, and margins vs sector.
Compare